Baby I Love You (3 melodies)
This is an experiment with AI: Suno.com
Extract of one of my songs: Baby I Love You.
First verse and chorus. 3 melodies.
1- My own melody (my voice + ukulele)
2- Suno melody (female voice)
3- Suno melody (male voice)
https://soundcloud.com/user-380042223/babyiloveyou-ukeguy-sunofemale-male
[verse]
This is another sleepless night
Where I can't get you off my mind.
I'm dreaming of that pure delight
When I'll get home and you'll be mine.
[chorus]
Oh Baby, I lo-ove you.
Baby, I love you-ooo.
Oh Baby, I lo-ove you.
Baby, I love you.
Comments
-
Had to see you here Guy0
-
Well I think all three of those work! Suno doesn't always get it right, but I think it's done a decent job here.
I guess it depends on how well the AI is matching what you want for the song.
0 -
Well done, liked all three, use Suno for my lyrics.
Female's usually better than male,
prompt soft rock rather than country
does soul really well
If you find a good prompt for a decent intro please let me know
mine just starts right at the first verse.
Thanks for sharing.
Sid
0 -
Man that sounds real, I’m impressed
These robots will replace us yet0 -
This really expands what you are able to do.0
-
Well I'm a fan of your uke style songs and I really like your voice. The AI is very clever and it's only going to get better, but it just sounds rather generic to me - both male and female. Would I have known if you hadn't said? Probably not, but my analysis would have been the same (I think).
0 -
As a modest lyricist and a big fan of Ai, I would like to tender these comments.
I've used Ai on my songs for the last 3-4 weeks. At this point I can offer these objective opinions.
RDM is right when he says that Ai's output is decent. That is a fair and objective assessment from a qualified musician.
From the pov of a lyricist, it is a godsend, it is the only viable, affordable way to hear your words put to some form of music and sung.
As to the quality of Ai output, it is still highly random and extremely restrictive in many aspects of music and vocals.
At present using Suno, the actual success rate for getting something decent first time is about 20%.
I have never heard an Ai song that I could not discern as being Ai, there are just too many shortfalls to ignore.
A typical Ai assisted song I post has dozens of shortcomings, but I accept them as it is better than nothing.
Realistically, I think it is easy to be blinded by the hype and innovation, but if you take a step back and compare objectively, I believe you will see it is more a case of "the Emperors new clothes."
If you haven't already, go into General Discussions and read RDM's Ai Experiment, good debate on Ai.
Sid
0 -
I listened again , I'd finish the female part , It sounds pretty real , that male does sound like a robot . Though the girl gets away with singing baby I love you in chorus , you might want to write a stronger chorus
0
Howdy, Stranger!